Dogs have been our loyal companions for thousands of years, but if you’ve ever seen your gentle pup suddenly transform at the sight of a squirrel, you may have wondered – are dogs predators? The answer isn’t quite so simple.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: While domestic dogs are not obligate carnivores like cats and retain many juvenile traits into adulthood, most dogs do still have predatory instincts and can be predators given the right circumstances and motivations.

In this approximately 3000 word article, we’ll take an in-depth look at the evolutionary history of dogs to understand their classification as predators. We’ll cover topics like:

– The difference between predators and scavengers

– How the domestication process changed dogs’ hunting behaviors

– Breed differences in prey drive

– Why some dogs do still kill small animals

– How to curb predatory behaviors in your own dog

Defining Predators vs. Scavengers

Scavengers – Animals That Eat Dead Meat

Scavengers are animals that feed on dead animals they did not kill themselves (National Geographic). They play an important ecological role by consuming dead organic matter and preventing the spread of diseases. Well-known scavengers include vultures, hyenas, raccoons, rats, and blowflies.

Researchers estimate over 95% of a wolf’s diet comes from scavenged carcasses rather than live prey (Yellowstone Wolf).

Scavenging helps many species survive when prey is scarce. Obligate scavengers like vultures rely solely on carrion while facultative scavengers like dogs opportunistically feed on carcasses. In fact, the dog’s flexible diet of both scavenged meat and hunted prey helped it develop a close relationship with humans.

Still, most dogs prefer fresh meat and will hunt small animals when possible.

True Predators – Animals That Kill Prey

In contrast to scavengers, true predators kill and eat live animals. Examples are lions, wolves, foxes, crocodiles, hawks, killer whales and spider wasps. Their prey includes herbivores like deer as well as smaller predators.

Predators help regulate prey species populations and cull sick or weak individuals.

However, predation impacts more than just prey numbers. A leading hypothesis proposes predator presence causes physiological changes in prey species, affecting reproduction and vigilance (Wiley). There is also evidence predators influence the feeding behavior of prey animals.

So while predators may feed on relatively few individuals, their indirect effects on prey ecology are significant.

The Origins of Dogs: Predators or Scavengers?

Theories on Dog Domestication

There are several theories on how dogs became domesticated from their wolf ancestors. Many experts believe it was a mutual relationship, with early hunter-gatherers working together with wolves for survival. Humans provided food leftovers, while wolves helped with hunting and protection.

This symbiotic relationship led to natural selection favoring friendlier wolves who were less afraid of humans. Over thousands of years, these protodogs evolved into the domestic dogs we know today.

Wolves as Apex Predators

Wolves are highly effective predators and hunt in packs to take down large prey like deer, elk, and bison. They have powerful jaws, sharp teeth, and quick reflexes ideal for seizing and killing prey. As apex predators, wolves play an important ecological role in regulating populations of herbivores.

Wolves are so adept at hunting that they can successfully capture up to 80% of the prey they attack.

Early Dogs as Scavengers

In contrast to wolves, early dogs were likely not skilled hunters but rather scavengers. They lacked the physical attributes and cooperative hunting behaviors seen in wolves. Instead of actively pursuing and killing prey, protodogs were opportunistic feeders, rummaging through waste areas near human camps for leftovers.

This shift from predator to scavenger was a key step in domestication. Over time, the evolutionary pressure for hunting skills diminished as dogs came to rely on humans for sustenance.

How Domestication Changed Dogs’ Hunting Instincts

Physical Changes

Over thousands of years of domestication, dogs have undergone significant physical changes compared to their wild wolf ancestors. Some of the key physical adaptations that impacted their hunting abilities include:

  • Smaller skulls and weaker jaws – Dogs have much weaker bite force than wolves, making it harder for them to kill large prey.
  • Reduced olfactory capabilities – Dogs have a far weaker sense of smell than wolves, which is critical for tracking prey.
  • Greater variability in size – Dogs come in a huge range of sizes, while wolves have a more uniform size adapted for taking down prey.
  • Shorter legs – Longer legs enable wolves to run down prey over long distances, while many dogs have shorter legs unsuited for endurance hunting.

These physical changes significantly reduced the ability of most dogs to effectively hunt prey compared to wolves.

Behavioral Changes

In addition to physical changes, domesticated dogs have undergone major behavioral changes that altered their predatory instincts:

  • Reduced pack hunting – Wolves rely heavily on coordinated pack hunting, while most dogs today live solitary lives or in smaller family groups.
  • Less territoriality – Dogs are less territorial than wolves, making them less inclined to actively patrol and defend a hunting ground.
  • Increased sociability – Dogs are able to develop social relationships with other species, including humans, rather than viewing them solely as prey.
  • Earlier socialization – Wolves have a short early socialization window, while dogs can be socialized to humans and other dogs for a much longer period as puppies.
  • Reduced wariness – Dogs are less cautious around humans and unfamiliar environments compared to wild wolves.

These behavioral adaptations allowed dogs to interact safely with humans and reduced their instinctive predatory behaviors.

Dogs Retain Some Predatory Behaviors

While domestic dogs are significantly less adept hunters than their wolf ancestors, some predatory instincts and capabilities remain:

  • Stalking behaviors – Dogs may instinctively stalk small animals like squirrels and cats even with no intention to hunt.
  • Chasing – The instinct to chase fleeing animals remains strong in many dogs.
  • Scavenging – Free-ranging dogs are effective opportunistic scavengers of carrion and human refuse.
  • Killing small vertebrates – Some dogs may kill small animals like rats, rabbits or feral cats, even with ample food.
  • Breed differences – Sighthounds and terriers tend to retain stronger predatory behaviors than other types of dogs.[1]

So while domestic dogs are not the effective pack hunters that wolves are, components of their hunting instinct remain even after thousands of years of domestication.

Breed Differences in Prey Drive

Herding Breeds

Herding breeds like Border Collies, Australian Shepherds, and German Shepherds have an innate instinct to gather and drive livestock. Selectively bred for their intense focus and drive, these intelligent pups often direct their hardwired herding behavior towards smaller moving objects if they do not have an adequate herding job.

This translates into a strong desire to chase down rabbits, squirrels, birds, mice, and other small critters that exhibit movement and triggering a keen prey drive (around a 3 on a scale of 5). Without proper training and mental stimulation, herding breeds may obsessively stalk backyard wildlife.

Owners should provide engaging play, obedience training, or even herding trials to satisfy their working dog’s instincts.

Terriers

Feisty terriers were originally bred to hunt and eliminate rodents and vermin. Their incredible prey drive and determination to ferret out hidden quarry and chase it down 9 persistence typifies breeds like Jack Russel Terriers, Rat Terriers, and Cairn Terriers (scoring a 4-5 on prey drive).

These tenacious pups think everything is fair game to kill, maim or consume, including mice, squirrels, rabbits, moles, rats, opossums, birds, snakes, lizards, frogs, and even deer/bucks if given the chance! Without sufficient mental stimulation, they are prone to neurotic, obsessive chasing.

Owners must provide consistent diversionary play and training to curb nuisance wildlife killing.

Scent Hounds

The superior scenting abilities of hounds like Beagles, Bloodhounds, Coonhounds, Foxhounds, and Basset Hounds have made them prized hunting partners for centuries. When their nose catches an intriguing odor, most throw themselves into tracking it relentlessly for miles (topping out prey drive at 5).

Once treed or cornered, they will aggressively bark and give chase until called off by their hunter companion. Allowed off-leash, they readily go AWOL when catching a good scent trail. These independent thinkers need strong recalls and should only be let off-leash in safely enclosed areas.

Retrievers

While sporting group dogs like Labradors, Goldens, Flat-Coated Retrievers live to fetch, they generally have more moderate prey drives (around 2-3). Selectively bred by hunters to retrieve downed waterfowl after the shot, they exhibit focus, patience and a soft mouth grip ideal for carrying birds without damage.

Their high energy and play drive are easily channeled into non-destructive toy play or rigorous exercise. Well-exercised retrievers are usually reliable off leash and less likely to wander. However, access wildlife may prove too tempting, so supervision is still required.

Retrievers thrive best with plenty of playful interaction.

Breed Group Prey Drive Rating Typical Prey Targets
Herding Dogs 3 Small critters like rabbits, squirrels etc.
Terriers 4-5 Mice, rats, rabbits, birds etc.
Scent Hounds 5 Deer, foxes, raccoon etc.
Retrievers 2-3 Usually retrievable prey like birds only

In the end, responsible pet owners must provide sufficient physical and mental exercise tailored to their dog’s breed traits and prey drive tendencies. Supervision, training recalls, puzzle toys and engaging play help satisfy hunting urges and prevent nuisance chasing.

For more tips check out sites like akc.org.

Why Dogs Sometimes Kill Small Animals

Canines can occasionally kill small critters even when they are not hungry. Determining the reasons behind this behavior requires an examination into their primal drives versus modern domestication.

Instinct vs. Play

The prey drive is deeply ingrained in dogs’ DNA as hunters. When they spot a squirrel or rabbit, their instinct kicks in to chase it down. However, most pet dogs do not need to hunt to survive. The urge may persist as a vestigial instinct they have not lost from their lupine ancestors.

It can also manifest in a form of amusement, much like how cats play with their food when not hungry.

Hunting for Food

In the wild, wolves and other canine species hunt small mammals for sustenance. The skill evolves from generation to generation to increase their odds of survival. This instinctive drive to catch prey remains within domesticated dogs.

If a canine lacks proper nourishment from its owners, it may resort to scavenging whatever animals it can capture. Proper feeding and access to food are essential to curtail hunting solely for hunger.

Predation vs. Prey Drive

The terms “prey drive” and “predation” differentiate between sport and food acquisition in canine hunting behaviors. Prey drive refers to the hardwired urge to chase small fast-moving animals, whether or not the dog intends to eat it.

In contrast, predation involves deliberately hunting for food consumption. Responsible pet owners must recognize these drives in dogs to mitigate unwanted killings of local wildlife or even small pets.

Training approaches focus on redirection and discouragement tactics to control their natural impulses.

Prey Drive Predation
Instinctive urge to chase critters Purposeful hunting for food
May not intend to eat the animal Goal is sustenance from the kill
Can manifest as play behavior Serves survival needs

Curbing Predatory Behaviors in Dogs

Start Training Early

It’s crucial to start training and socializing your dog from an early age to curb predatory behaviors. Puppies start learning from the moment they open their eyes – take advantage of this impressionable time to teach good manners and obedience.

Attend puppy kindergarten classes, expose your dog to new sights and sounds, and teach “leave it” and “drop it” commands. If you adopt an adult dog with an established hunting drive, early training is still beneficial, though it may take more time and patience.

Provide Adequate Exercise & Stimulation

Dogs were bred to work – they need activity to be happy and well-behaved. A tired dog is a good dog! Make sure your pooch gets sufficient physical and mental exercise every day. Go for long walks, play fetch or tug, take hiking adventures, enroll in agility or nosework classes, use food puzzles/chew toys, and provide access to a safe, enriched yard.

Prevent boredom and excess energy, which can increase the urge to hunt. As the saying goes, “A busy dog is a good dog!”

Use Distractions

When you spot potential “prey” like a squirrel or rabbit, distract your dog before they fixate and slip into hunt mode. Excitedly call their name, ask for a trick, initiate play, or walk/run in the opposite direction.

You want to redirect their attention and avoid triggering that instinctive drive to give chase. Bring tasty treats on walks to further distract from outdoor stimuli. With proper conditioning, your dog will learn to ignore rather than chase critters. Distract, don’t restrain!

Consider Medications or Supplements

In extreme cases, medications or supplements may help dial down predatory urges. Consult your vet about options like fluoxetine or clomipramine for anxiety/compulsion issues. Natural calming supplements like melatonin, tryptophan, CBD oil, chamomile, and L-theanine are gentler alternatives.

Note that medication is not a cure-all and should be used alongside training. Never give your dog supplements without vet approval.

The key to curbing hunting behaviors in dogs is early socialization, lots of exercise, distraction/redirection, and potentially medication for severe cases. With time, consistency, and positive reinforcement, you can help even high-prey drive breeds become model canine citizens.

Patience and persistence are key – don’t get frustrated, your efforts will pay off!

Conclusion

While domesticated dogs are not obligate predators like wolves, they do retain some of their hunting ancestry and predator classification through breed traits and instinct. However, dogs’ natural hunting behaviors can be shaped through proper training and care.

Understanding your dog’s unique prey drive and providing adequate outlets can allow your pup’s inner predator to live peacefully alongside squirrels, rabbits, and other small animals.

Similar Posts