The tiger salamander and the axolotl may look similar at first glance, but they are actually quite different amphibians. If you’re wondering how to tell these two creatures apart, read on to learn all about their unique features and characteristics.

In short, while both are salamanders, the tiger salamander is terrestrial while the axolotl stays aquatic its whole life. Tiger salamanders have warty skin and muted coloration for camouflage, whereas axolotls have frilly gills and bright, vivid colors.

Appearance and Physical Features

Skin Texture and Coloration

Tiger salamanders have thick, warty skin that can range in color from yellowish-green to dark brown or black. They often have striking yellow, orange, or white markings, spots, or blotches on their backs and sides.

These bright colors serve as a warning to predators that tiger salamanders secrete toxins from their skin. Axolotls have smooth, moist skin that lacks scales or warts. Their skin can be various shades of brown, gray, olive green, or pinkish white.

Unlike tiger salamanders, axolotls do not produce toxic secretions from their skin.

Size and Weight

On average, tiger salamanders are larger and heavier than axolotls. Adult tiger salamanders are 6-9 inches long and can weigh around 115-250 grams. Axolotls are smaller, growing to around 6-9 inches long and weighing 25-70 grams.

The largest tiger salamanders can reach up to 14 inches long, while axolotls rarely exceed 10 inches in length. So in terms of sheer size, the tiger salamander is often the more imposing of the two species.

Gills

One of the most noticeable physical differences between tiger salamanders and axolotls is the retention of gills into adulthood. Axolotls famously maintain their frilly external gills and remain aquatic for life.

Tiger salamanders, on the other hand, lose their gills as they mature and transition from an aquatic larval stage to a mostly terrestrial adult form. On very rare occasions, a mature tiger salamander may fail to undergo metamorphosis and retain its gills, but unlike the axolotl, this is not the normal course of development.

Habitats and Behavior

Natural Habitats

Tiger salamanders and axolotls have very different natural habitats. Tiger salamanders are found throughout most of North America, ranging from Canada to Mexico. They prefer cooler climates and are usually found in forests, grasslands and prairies near sources of water like ponds or streams.

Axolotls are only native to Lake Xochimilco and Lake Chalco in central Mexico. These high altitude lakes provided the perfect aquatic habitat for axolotls.

Tiger salamanders spend most of their adult life on land, only returning to water to breed. They can be found under logs, rocks or burrowing underground. Axolotls remain aquatic their entire lives. They live at the bottom of lakes, moving slowly along the muddy bottom and hiding among plants and rocks.

Diet and Hunting

Both tiger salamanders and axolotls are carnivores and voracious predators. Tiger salamanders hunt worms, insects, slugs and small vertebrates like fish, frogs and snakes. They use their keen sense of smell to locate prey and then ambush them with their large mouths and fast-moving tongues.

Axolotls use similar hunting techniques, consuming small fish, aquatic insects and worms.

An interesting difference is that axolotls hunt primarily using suction. By opening their mouths wide, they can suck their prey in from several inches away. Tiger salamanders rely more on their tongue to capture and manipulate food.

Their diet generally consists of larger prey that requires more effort to subdue and consume.

Breeding and Life Cycle

The breeding habits of tiger salamanders and axolotls are adapted to their different habitats. Tiger salamanders migrate to ponds and lay eggs in large clumps during the spring. There can be over 1,000 eggs in a single clutch! The eggs hatch into aquatic larvae with gills.

They eventually transform into terrestrial adults and leave the water. Axolotls breed year round and the females lay smaller clutches of around 300 eggs. The eggs hatch and the offspring remain aquatic and retain many larval features, like gills.

Tiger salamanders have a complex metamorphosis and transition from larvae to adult as they mature. Axolotls exhibit a phenomenon called neoteny, where they retain most of their larval characteristics for their entire lifespan.

As a result, axolotls remain fully aquatic and never lose their gills to become terrestrial. Their development is paedomorphic, meaning they reach sexual maturity without undergoing metamorphosis.

Conservation Status

Threats Facing Each Species

Both tiger salamanders and axolotls face numerous threats that have led to population declines and increased vulnerability. Here are some of the major threats:

  • Habitat loss and degradation – Their wetland habitats have been drained and developed, reducing available habitat.
  • Pollution – Runoff from agricultural and urban areas introduces toxins and sediments into their aquatic environments.
  • Non-native species – The introduction of predatory fish, bullfrogs, and other species has increased predation and competition.
  • Climate change – Rising temperatures and altered precipitation patterns further threaten already diminished habitats.
  • Disease – Chytrid fungus has devastated some amphibian populations, including axolotls.

Axolotls face the additional threat of overcollection. They are highly popular as pets and for laboratory research. Extensive removal from the wild has drastically reduced their numbers.

Protection Efforts

Several conservation measures aim to protect tiger salamanders and axolotls:

  • Legal protections – Tiger salamanders are not federally listed but receive some regional protections. Axolotls are Critically Endangered and protected under Mexican law.
  • Captive breeding – Zoos and aquariums breed axolotls for reintroduction. Some tiger salamanders are also captive bred as pets.
  • Habitat preservation – Protecting remaining wetlands and restoring degraded habitats helps safeguard wild populations.
  • Reduced collection – Limits on axolotl collection help stabilize numbers. Pet trade restrictions also help tiger salamanders.
  • Research – Studies aim to boost scientific knowledge to better manage wild populations. Gene banks preserve axolotl genetic diversity.

However, significant challenges remain. Continued habitat loss, limited regulatory protection, and persistent threats pose ongoing risks. Long-term population viability will require expanded habitat protections and mitigation of key threats for both species.

Conclusion

While tiger salamanders and axolotls occupy different ecological niches, both play important roles in their respective environments. Understanding the unique adaptations and lifestyles of each species can help motivate conservation efforts.

Hopefully this overview has helped highlight the key differences and similarities between these fascinating amphibians. Let us know in the comments if you have any other salamander questions!

Similar Posts